from mileberg.louie
My experience and struggle cooking a good Italian style bolognese + new recipe:
On the 23rd of December 2024 i posted, 'louie milebergs famous bolognaise recipe'. At the time of writing this up, i believed i had fine-tuned the classic ragu well enough to post this perfect recipe. However, as of now (16th of February 2025) i disagree with what i wrote in the original, and am here to amend it with reasoning.
Big Disclaimer: Not to get too bulked down on what makes a good 'traditional' bolognese, as i believe recipes should only be used as a guide and should be adjusted to however you may want. Theres a huge discussion on whether to include garlic in a bolognese, and during my recent bolognese epiphany of the last week, i was chatting to a mate from Naples and they said do not put garlic in for traditional sake. So here ive chosen not to. However this recipe is a mere guide and how i would chose to go about it, if you like garlic put some in or anything you want itll still be delicious. But here my goal was deliciousness and traditional, so i will follow that in the recipe.
Sofrito: – 1 Large onion – 4 ribs of celery – 2 carrots – With a fine dice on all
Ragu: – Ground beef (90/10 or 80/20) – Tomato Paste – Beef stock cube – Dry red wine – Fresh herbs of your choice (Bayleaf, thyme, basil) – Water
Step 1: Heat up an oven-proof safe pot on a medium heat (4/5) with a splash of olive oil. No need for excessive amounts
Step 2: Once you believe the oil is heated, you will test it. Add a small amount of your sofrito into the pan and listen out, you want to hear an immediate sizzle when the veg hits the oil. If not, let it heat up for a few more minutes. If an immediate sizzle, add in the rest.
Step 3: Cook on a low heat for around 25 minutes, it should almost blend all together and be soft and nearly dissolve into 1. There should be no visible chunks of any veg if the dice was fine enough. I like to mash the veg around with a wooden spoon just to crush it up even finer.
Step 4: When the veg is soft and a mass of 1, push to the side and add in our beef. We should still have a bit of oil on the bottom of our pan. Break the ground beef up into small chunks and push it down into the oil making good contact with the oil and base of the pan. I like to do mine in small batches. Here we will leave these to brown. Constantly check for browning on the bottom of the searing beef to make sure its browning or not burning.
Step 5: After maybe 4/5 ish minutes we flip the beef and repeat on the other side but just aim to cook out the raw colour. Once finished, push beef into the pile of veg and make it fuse into 1. Then add in the rest of the ground beef (if chose to be done in batches) and then once rawness cooked out just fuse into the pile of beefy veg.
Step 6: Add in the tomato paste just maybe a table spoon and a bit. Leave it to fry in the bottom of the pan for a maybe a minute just to cook out the rawness. Then use wooden spoon to mix into the veg and beef.
Step 7: Adding in the wine. I first initally push the beef pile onto one side, turn the heat up and pour in a small amount of wine almost creating a small well of wine thatll quickly evapourate. I believe both cooking with your nose and heat control is important here. Turn the heat up after the wine goes in and it should immediately start to boil, you should get hit with a strong alcohol up your nose that makes you take a step back. Once this first bit of wine has cooked out, add in more and push the veg/beef into it. Lower heat back to medium, add in more wine – I ended up using about just over 1/3 of the bottle and just let it cook out for around 5 minutes.
Step 8: Add in beef stock cube and then fill up with water. This will be cooking low and slow for hours in the oven (or stove i just chose oven) so too much liquid doesnt matter. We have a lot of time to reduce.
Step 9: Bring up to a simmer, and place into a preheated oven of around 120 degrees c with a lid slightly cracked. Cook for an hour, hour and a half maybe and there would be slight reduction. Cooking time really varies, i today had mine cooking for about 3 and a half hours in total. Your time can be completely adjusted to fit your needs. It is just important to cook uncovered to allow brownness to develop on the side of the dish. This can be scraped with a wooden spoon into the sauce – check on this regularly.
Step 10: Serve with pasta and enjoy
What led me to believe the original recipe needed adjusting: During my week-long bolognese ephinany, id be reading about how a blend of pork and beef should really be used for a bolognese. I had remembered seeing a packet sold in lidl which contained 250g of ground beef and 250g of ground pork – so i thought would be perfect. However, the only item i could find was a 500g blend of both pork and ground beef and thought id take a punt and try it. I believe this bolognese was genuinely unenjoyable and almost horrible.
I had 2 problems with it – The meat flavour was horrible – It was overly sweet
This cheap lidl pork beef blend allowed me to realise the importance of high quality beef in a bolognese, as at its forefront it is a meat sauce. The cheap pork flavour with the overly sweetness was really really bad and i couldnt end up finishing it. (Read on for overly sweetness)
Changes from the original:
From 1 to 2 carrots in the sofrito and the importance of a fine dice:
This is our first change from the original recipe. I initially stated to use 1 carrot as theyre quite sweet, and did state a fine-dice was needed. However ive realised 2 carrots is more appropriate and i cannot emphaise enough the importance of a fine dice. When i used to make it, i didnt dice the carrot up enough – and whilst the onion and celery would blend and dissolve into the meat sauce – the carrot would always remain structured and almost leave chunks throughout. Biting down on these chunks would add unneccessary sweetness and sometimes made the dish far too sweet and really not great. Ive since learnt the importance of a FINE dice, we need these carrots small so they are able to blend into the sauce. Because of the removal of chunks, ive found using more carrots (1 to 2) is important as the sweetness is more subtle and not a complete burst of overpowering sweet flavour.
Removal of the draining of fat colinder method:
Cant be bothered to do this , dont believe theres any need just scape fat off using spoon after cooking if really can be bothered but doesnt make a difference – unless using unbelievably fatty beef then no need i dont think.
Removal of tinned tomatoes:
The biggest change in this recipe is the removal of the tins of tomatoes. Any bolognese ive ever really made at its core was a tomato meat sauce. However, traditionally a bolognese is a meat sauce at its front, and i think is actually better without an overpowering tomato flavour. Whilst there are hints (the added tomato paste), it is more used to add body to the sauce and less tomato flavour itself. I think removing the tinned tomatos allow the flavours of the sofrito to shine and create a much richer and more enjoyable meat sauce compared to the tomato-based one we might commonly know.
More wine and added beef stock:
Quite obvious, due to lack of any tomato flavour we add more wine adding more richness and flavour to the meat sauce. I believe viewing the way to cook a bolognese almost as if its a red-wine braised stew allows for a more delicious flavour and overall better experience. Furthermore, using beef stock just creates an meatier flavour with more body and thus makes more sense than just plain water.
My first experience cooking the new bolognese, important notes and friends reviews:
Tonight i attempted to make my new developed recipe and it was overall a success. The ragu was deliciouslly rich and a very enjoyable meal.
However, there are some important disclaimers i must make:
When i made this today, i only used 1 carrot in my sofrito due to my past experiences of over-sweetness. Here in the recipe ive doubled it to 2. I found that the ragu would have benefited with a more round flavour of sweetness and i ended up adding sugar to fight off the dry-ness of the red wine.
Furthermore, i found the ragu to be slightly overseasoned. I would always salt at every stage when making my initial ragu and didnt think to do anything different today. However, due to the new addition of beef stock – that contians a high amount of sodium which led to the sauce being too salty. I was able to combat this by not salting my pasta water, and adding some acid (lemon juice) to take the salty edge off. I also believe the addition of an extra carrot like in the point above would have been able to fight some of the salt.
I cooked this ragu for the first time hosting dinner for 2 of my mates and was met with raving reviews:
One guest stated: 'Wow this is amazing', 'I've had worse in restaurants'
Another guest stated: 'This isnt too salty' – but they have a serious sodium palette problem
Overall i believe this was a success and i will be cooking my bolognese like this onwards.